In other to set up a recording studio or get a quality sound experience, it is necessary to have quality sets of speakers. Not just any kind of speaker, but the one which is capable of bringing to you a nice clear and amplified sound to your hearing.
It is important to know the kind of speaker which will give you the perfect sound to suit your desires at a particular time as there are different kinds, brands, and models of speakers producing different kinds of sound as the case may be. The choice of a speaker depends on the space where it is being used or purposes it is being used for because there are different kinds of speakers which is specifically used by the DJs, the one which is usually used in recording studios and the one which is suitable for in the house. One needs to understand the concept behind this before setting out to buy a speaker.
Today, we will be making our comparison between two speakers which are one of the most marketed in the market. The two companies have been up to protect their reputation by producing quality and durable speakers. We will be narrowing our comparison to Yamaha HS5 and JBL 305P MkII speakers. As a sound engineer who recognizes a good speaker producing a good sound, these two speakers produce amazing sound. But by the time we are done making our comparison, you will be sure of the kind of speaker to purchase. The comparison tends to cover the price tag, bodily design, and of course the quality of sound produced by each speaker. So let us dive into action.
PRICE:
This is one of the most essential factors to be considered before setting out to buy a product, especially speakers. It is necessary to have enough bucks on you if you don’t want to buy an “anyhow” product. As an individual either sound engineer or casual listener who wants to sharpen their listening experience, you should be able to save enough bucks to purchase a quality speaker instead of wasting money on sub-standard speakers.
Yamaha HS5 is priced at $200 while the JBL 305p MkII is priced at $167.
The Verdict:
Economically, the price of Yamaha HS5 is on the high side and more expensive compared to JBL 305p MkII. This is a disadvantage on the part of the Yamaha as some may not be able to afford to purchase it. Some will rather go for the JBL 305p MkII speaker.
DESIGN:
It’s easy to get caught up in the size and design of the monitor when it comes to professional sound production. Some people are drawn to speakers with greater size or a trendier, even innovative appearance. The bodily design of a product matters most not only does it attract people but also renders the product marketable. It is easy to catch the attention of a customer through the bodily structure or how attractive a product is. In this section, we shall be considering the two speakers and make our comparison concerning the structure of the two products.
Yamaha HS5
The Yamaha HS5 speaker is a very attractive speaker. It has a wooden casing that houses the woofer and the tweeter. Yamaha HS5 is designed in both black and white. The technological advances in the new HS5 design are extremely astounding, and it’s even sweeter that Yamaha didn’t place the model in an entirely new pricing group. As a result, the speaker is still accessible to practically everyone interested in learning more about great music production and mixing.
Independent amplifiers for the woofer which is 5-inch in size and tweeter are included in the design, providing more frequency and isolation enhanced performance for each. Furthermore, they are not underpowered and possess sufficient zeal to complete the task without having to compete for the power of a shared source. It has a weight of 11.68 which is equivalent to 5.298kilograms.
JBL 305P MkII:
The box is solid black with a clean, gleaming plastic surface. It’s dazzling without giving off the same over-the-top vibe as certain studio monitors.
They stand out from the matte-looking monitors that now dominate the studio monitor market. Don’t get me wrong: there are considerably more significant factors to consider when choosing a studio monitor than its aesthetics. That doesn’t rule out the possibility of appreciating something that looks as good as it sounds. JBL has been manufacturing speakers for almost 70 years and has earned a reputation for high-quality construction. Although it may be too early in the latest generation MkII’s life cycle to make a firm judgment.
They weigh a little over 10 pounds which is equivalent to 4.5kg and have a solid feel to them. All of the components are safely housed in a strong cabinet.
The Verdict:
Based on the bodily comparison of the two speakers, the two speakers have an astonishing and mind-blowing design. Yamaha is a 2-way design as they can be in either white or black color. It is not every time a buyer may be interested in buying just one color design. Black is a common color of the design of speakers but Yamaha has stepped up their game by producing a white-colored speaker.
The JBL 305p MkII is also awarded credit for the shiny plastic finish at the front of the speaker. This makes this speaker to be noticed wherever it is being placed.
The weight of a speaker also determines the interest of the buyer in making their choice, in making a comparison between two speakers, we tend to weigh them and determine the one that is lighter than the other. At times, the lighter speaker is a chance while the other is despised. Therefore the JBL 305p MkII is preferred to the Yamaha HS5 speaker.
SOUND QUALITY:
The most essential aim why we opt out to purchase a speaker is to get a high-quality sound experience. This section is aimed at enlightening us all the quality of sound produced by these two speakers.
Yamaha HS5:
Yamaha’s black HS5 Powered Studio Monitor is a bi-amplified monitor with excellent sound reproduction in mind. It has a 5-inch woofer and a 1-inch tweeter with a waveguide that can create frequencies up to 30kHz and can provide up to 70W of total power. For fitting into a range of studio configurations, the HS5 offers both an XLR and a 1/4″ TRS input that accepts either balanced or unbalanced signals.
The designs of the speaker also contribute to the quality of sound that will be produced. A vortex at either end of the port can often cause undesired noise by creating air movements inside the port. Yamaha’s engineers were able to manage and decrease the vortex by using noise reduction technologies that included an examination of a visual depiction of the sound. Yamaha has developed a port design that decreases noise by up to 6dB as a result of this research.
JBL 305P MkII:
The small JBL LSR 305P MkII can achieve bass ranges that other five-inch devices can only dream of thanks to its innovative bass-reflex technology. The frequency response begins at a stunning 43 Hz and continues to 22 kHz. The substantially updated driver architecture produces excellent performance and exceptionally precise transient response.
A pair of settings for bass roll-off and a high shelf filter are located on the back panel, allowing you to fine-tune the sound to meet the environment. Separate power amplifiers with outputs of 41 watts each feed the five-inch woofer and one-inch tweeter. Due to its unique design, it has an in-built amplifier.
It can reach a maximum volume of 108dB, which is more than loud enough for a small studio and adequate for a medium-sized one. A subwoofer can still help, although this isn’t always the case.
The Verdict
It has been a tough one between the two speakers as they are both quality speakers producing quality sound. But as it has been reviewed, JBL 305p MkII is better than Yamaha HS5 in terms of comparison. The JBL 305p MkII has been given credits in terms of price as it is affordable compared to Yamaha HS5. One may tend to save or better still use the extra bucks to buy other sound-amplifying devices.
Although, the Yamaha HS5 design looks more attractive as they are designed in both white and black but the JBL 305p MkII has a shiny plastic finish which makes it more attractive to the buyer and it is also lighter in weight.
